KLINIK RESPIRASI. Klinik Dokter THT di Malang, Klinik Dokter Paru di Malang, Klinik Jantung di Malang, Klinik Dokter Paru di Surabaya, Klinik Dokter Penyakit Dalam di Malang, Klinik Dokter Gigi di Malang, Klinik Dokter Gigi di Serpong

Berita Kesehatan

Factors limiting the utility of bronchoalveolar lavage in the diagnosis of Covid-19

Image : https://cdn0-production-images-kly.akamaized.net/oi4dKUUx5LlqjfDIDCamByxB5cs=/640x360/smart/filters:quality(75):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/kly-media-production/medias/3097828/original/096061400_1586403973-concept-of-covid-19-in-red-background-4031867.j

Selasa, 01 Sep 2020 14:00:00

Deepak Aggarwal, Varinder Saini

European Respiratory Journal 2020; DOI: 10.1183/13993003.03116-2020

Bronchoalveolar lavage has a specific place in the diagnosis of Covid-19. The clinical performance of BAL rRt-PCR is dynamic in nature and depends on different clinical and demographic factors.

We read with interest study by Geri et al. in which the authors have demonstrated a strong agreement between negative nasopharyngeal (NPs)/nasal (Ns) swab and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (rRT-PCR) in the diagnosis of Covid-19 among hospitalised patients. The study findings contradicted earlier report and suggested a limited utility of BAL. However, the results need to be interpreted comprehensively before drawing any conclusion.

In the present study, BAL was negative for SARS-CoV-2 by rRT-PCR in majority of cases that included 38 patients (48%) with strong clinical and radiological suspicion for Covid-19. This finding implies either a high false negative rate of BAL rRT-PCR or an alternate diagnosis. Hence, authors should give a detail account of the final diagnoses and treatment outcomes of the patients and correlate these with the rRT-PCR results. This will give a better picture of the clinical performance of rRT-PCR in both BAL and upper respiratory samples.

Clinical test performance of rRT-PCR (in BAL/Ns/NPs) is a dynamic parameter that depends not only on its analytic sensitivity but also on the pretest probability. The pretest probability may in turn depend on the SARS-CoV-2 exposure history, disease symptoms and local disease prevalence. The unexpected low positivity seen with BAL rRT-PCR in the study despite high pretest probability might be due to delayed time of sampling and/or disease stage. All these factors should have been considered while comparing the diagnostic yield in the study

Bronchoalveolar lavage has a specific place in the diagnostic algorithm of Covid-19 and is usually performed in a patient with lower respiratory tract involvement and high clinical suspicion but negative Ns/NPs result. However, negative BAL results should be interpreted comprehensively in light of different clinical and demographic factors on a case-to-case basis.